untamed.nl
 


'more tears are shed over answered prayers than unanswered ones..'
(Philip Seymour Hoffman, Capote)

V for Vendetta
V for Vendetta

 

Su-ki-da
Su-ki-da

I can't help but chuckle when someone on a forum asks whether people ever cry at a movie. It's like asking if I sneeze when my nose is being tickled with a feather, a rhetorical and immature question. I used to cry buckets, almost every night. In the last couple of years a balance has been found that normal people might consider healthier. They're wrong.

Natalie Portman is no stranger to the salty water: over someone else's loss, a boyfriend or the whole world, arms raised in the rain, she even admitted looking forward to a good cry in Garden State. In fact, these scenes are so riveting that they can't be discussed here, for fear of repetition. A lot of other great weepies shall be shamelessly ignored, because of high overall positions and/or inclusion in the depression category. What more than Aoi Miyazaki in distress, waiting in silence for seventeen years after taking her breakdown time against the cloudy blue sky of Su-ki-da, does a movie lover need anyway? Tears should never be overanalyzed, so we'll keep it relatively brief. Also, there's the matter of privacy: some tearjerks are too recent and personal, call it a secret and everyone will start fantasizing, to share with the rest of the world, yet. I admit, such a rare occasion happened only Once, but it's important enough to mention, if only as proof that I'm not the tragic 100% exhibitionist I sometimes seem to be. Enough about me already, let's hand out the prizes!

Touched

 

An honorary award goes to Touched (2005, Timothy Scott Bogart). This based on a true story tv drama stars Jenna Elfman, Randall Batinkoff and Samantha Mathis, in probably the biggest sentimental manipulation in history. It's about a man who awakes from a coma, finds out his son is dead and his nurse has the hots for him. Sounds excruciatingly bad? It is and it ain't! Its honesty becomes nervewrecking, when you let yourself go with the flow and try to imagine how YOU would react if a loved one returned from the dead. Touched is exceptionally over the top, really, you've never seen anything this preposterous. It just screams for destruction of all intellectual reviewers forever, so help us God. Never rate or rank again, sounds great. For a while.

 

5. Heavenly Forest
(Tada, kimi wo aishiteru, 2006, Takehiko Shinjo)

When you grow up, your heart dies, with a twist. In Japanese divine looking Heavenly Forest a kind young man meets the most adorable quirky girl ever, Aoi Miyazaki again, who apparently only eats cute little donut biscuits. In the years that follow, the purest imaginable love will be cherished, kept within. Photographs at an exhibition and a whole bunch of letters gives crying over lost opportunities a new dimension. Melancholia with awareness that everything is forever.
 

Heavenly Forest
 
In America
 

4. In America
(2002, Jim Sheridan)

Mom, dad and young daughters all need to find their own way in shared grief over a lost son and brother. Eleven year old Christy rightfully declares she has been carrying the family on her back for the past year. Under a full moon, just before the credits roll, she finally sees her father's sorrow break through the choke. In America is magical.
 

3. Griffin & Phoenix
(2006, Ed Stone)

Two years ago, one by one, all my friends started to embrace this surprise, spinning a web of remembrance and compassion. Griffin & Phoenix is special because it has its big breaking point in the middle, not at the end like Grace Is Gone (and various other usual suspects). Emotions bursts through the roof when love obviously was meant to be. Because of terminal truth revealed.
 

Griffin & Phoenix
 

Sad Movie
 

2. Sad Movie
(2005, Jong-kwan Kon)

What's even more heartbreaking than crying thrice? Slowly accumulate all tears from various tragic stories for almost the entire length of the film, don't let them enter the eyes just yet. Show concerned love, dying family and other fiery scars, but with restraint. Then turn on a neverending hose. Sad Movie must be the most appropriate title ever: genuine Korean sentiment at its megamultiple supersoaking best.
 

1. Dancer in the Dark
(2000, Lars Von Trier)

Lightyears ahead of the rest, Dancer in the Dark could well be the most effective tearjerker ever made: injustice at its very worst triggers overwhelming memento of my own helplessness. Remembering specific scenes isn't even necessary for the eyes to go moist, writing about it has been postponed many times.
This managed to do for tears what The Exorcist did for fears, obliterating both heart and mind at a scary fundamental level.

Dancer in the Dark


(Menni, untamed.nl 2009)